All You Should Know about Discussion Text

H

i there! Have you ever found yourself caught between two sides of an argument, such as the pros and cons of school uniforms, social media, or online learning, and unsure which one makes more sense? That’s where discussion texts come in! They’re a great way to explore different perspectives on a topic and help you decide for yourself. Understanding how to write or analyze a discussion text can sharpen your critical thinking skills and make your writing more impactful. Let’s dive in and uncover everything you need to know about discussion texts!

1. What Is a Discussion Text?

Definition: A discussion text is a form of writing that explores different perspectives on an issue.
Examples of topics: Environmental issues, technological advancements, social debates, etc.
Purpose: To present balanced arguments (for and against) on a subject to encourage critical thinking and decision-making, helping readers make informed opinions.

2. Key Features of a Discussion Text

A. General Structure of Discussion texts

Discussion texts commonly consist of:

• Introduction: Introduces the issue and its relevance.
• Arguments for (Pros): Supporting points with logical reasoning and evidence.
• Arguments against (Cons): Opposing viewpoints with counter-evidence.
• Conclusion: Summarizes the discussion, providing possible recommendations or leaving the decision open to readers.

B. Language Features of Discussion texts

Arguments inside a discussion text are commonly presented using:

• Connectors: However, on the other hand, similarly, moreover.
• Modal verbs: Might, should, could to express possibilities and recommendations.
• Present tense: Frequently used to discuss ongoing or general issues.
• Passive voice: Often used for formality and objectivity.
• Balanced tone: Avoids personal bias or emotional language.

3. Examples of Discussion Text Topics

Here are examples of topics that you can explore. These examples highlight both relatable and thought-provoking issues that can engage readers.

• "Should homework be abolished in schools?"
• "Is online learning better than traditional classrooms?"
• "Does social media do more harm than good?"
• "Should plastic be banned completely?"

4. How to Write a Good Discussion Text

Here is a step-by-step guide in writing discussion texts:

1. Choose a debatable topic. Pick an issue with clear opposing viewpoints.
2. Research thoroughly. Gather evidence and examples for both sides of the argument.
3. Create an outline. Structure your text into introduction, pros, cons, and conclusion.
4. Write objectively. Use persuasive yet unbiased language to present arguments clearly.
5. Edit and proofread. Ensure coherence, grammatical accuracy, and a balanced presentation.

5. Common Mistakes in Writing Discussion Texts

When writing a discussion text, be sure to avoid:

• One-sided arguments
  Make sure you provide balanced pros and cons arguments. Presenting only the pros or cons weakens the balance.
• Personal bias or emotional tone
  Don't include your personal or emotional opinions as they may reduce credibility.
• Weak or irrelevant evidence
  Provide strong arguments and don't leave arguments unconvincing.
• Neglecting the conclusion
  Closing the discussion text, make sure to tie up the discussion or offer insights.

6. Why Learn About Discussion Texts?

Here are the benefits of learning about discussion texts:

• Enhancing critical thinking.
  With discussion texts, students learn to evaluate diverse viewpoints.
• Improving writing fluency
  Learning about discussion texts develops students' skills to argue logically and coherently.
• Practical applications
  It also helps prepare students for exams, academic writing, and real-world debates.

Continue to Sample Discussion Text

7. Sample Discussion Text

Below is an example of a discussion text.
Topic: Should school uniforms be mandatory?
Introduction: Discusses the relevance of school uniforms as a common debate in education.
Arguments for:

• Promotes discipline and reduces peer pressure.
• Fosters a sense of equality among students.

Arguments against:

• Limits personal expression.
• May not significantly impact academic performance.

Conclusion: Suggests a balanced approach, such as allowing optional uniforms or flexible policies.
Text example:

Should School Uniforms Be Mandatory?

(Introduction)

The debate over whether school uniforms should be mandatory has been a topic of discussion for years. Supporters argue that uniforms promote discipline and equality among students, while critics claim they limit personal expression and fail to address deeper educational issues. This discussion explores both perspectives to help readers form their own opinions on the matter.

(Arguments for school uniforms)

Advocates of school uniforms believe that they help create a sense of equality among students. By removing the pressure to wear trendy or expensive clothing, uniforms can reduce social barriers and prevent bullying based on appearance. Additionally, uniforms contribute to a sense of school pride and discipline. For instance, students dressed in uniforms are more likely to be perceived as serious and focused learners. Schools with uniform policies also report fewer distractions in the classroom, as students are less concerned about their outfits.

Another point in favor of uniforms is safety. Identical clothing makes it easier to identify students, which can help school authorities maintain security during events or emergencies. Uniforms also discourage the presence of gang-related clothing or inappropriate attire on school premises.

(Arguments against school uniforms)

On the other hand, opponents argue that school uniforms restrict students’ ability to express their individuality. Clothing is a form of self-expression, and enforcing uniforms can suppress creativity and personal freedom. Critics also question whether uniforms truly improve academic performance or behavior, as these issues are influenced by more complex factors like teaching quality and parental involvement.

Moreover, the cost of school uniforms can be a burden for some families. While the idea of reducing clothing expenses is often promoted, purchasing multiple sets of uniforms can be costly, especially for low-income households. Parents might also need to buy additional casual clothes for non-school hours, further increasing expenses.

(Conclusion)

The question of whether school uniforms should be mandatory does not have a simple answer. Uniforms offer benefits like fostering equality, promoting discipline, and enhancing safety, but they also pose challenges, such as limiting self-expression and creating financial burdens for some families. A balanced approach could involve making uniforms optional or allowing students to personalize their uniforms to some extent. Ultimately, schools need to consider their community’s values and priorities before deciding on a uniform policy.

The above text contains an introduction, two sides of an argument (pros and cons of school uniforms), and an impartial conclusion which suggests balance.

Now, please try writing your own discussion text using the tips and structure you have learned. You may explore one of the example topics provided above. Happy practising. See you in the next posts!🤗😊

12